phd researcher
nest trails by topic. pin the claim that matters. read the argument back.
trails that mirror the thesis
one reading day
classic three-network model. their "alerting" maps onto what i have been calling baseline arousal. the disagreement i care about is below.
the argument, in one scroll
the way back
the follow-ups and the open threads are marked ↻. choose attention for tomorrow's new page and they are already on it. only pins kept on attention itself come back this way: a pin kept on lit review shows in this list as inherited, but it does not land on an attention page. it happens once, when the page first joins the trail.
in the chapter 3 draft, type @ and pick the reading day. the draft gets a link to it, one click from the claim to the page where you worked it out. and search finds the paper you argued with in february, even the parts you never pinned.
why not a reference manager
a reference manager stores what you read. it cannot store what you thought about it, because the thinking happened somewhere else: in a margin, in a different app, or not at all. a notes app stores the thinking and then buries it under everything else you typed that term.
the pins on a topic trail are the claims you judged worth keeping, with the tables, figures and sources you pinned beside them, each one pointing back to the page where you worked it out. reorder them and you are already drafting the argument. that is a literature review with the reasoning intact rather than a bibliography with a summary bolted on afterwards.
and the reading days themselves stay in memory rather than following you forward. they are supposed to. most of what you write while working through a paper is you arguing with it, which is the work, not the output.